Categories > Other Products

The 5 Best Bakeries for Custom Cakes in Dallas Homepage

The 5 Best Bakeries for Custom Cakes in Dallas

How We Picked

Baker’s experience – The amount of relative baking experience accumulated over years of catering to different customers and events.
Overall creativity – How creative the bakery’s approaches are to any of its products, and how accurately it can satisfy each customer’s requested cake design.
Turnaround time – How efficient and timely it can create and deliver any requested orders.
Customer service – The overall experience of customers when working with the bakery’s management and staff.
Availability – How easy it is to access the bakery’s services through phone calls or walk-ins throughout the week.

1. Daisy Cakes

Daisy Cakes Homepage

Services and Options: Catering for Events, Whole Cakes, Assorted Cupcakes, Cookies, Various Cake Flavors, Fillings, Icing, etc.


Address: 5200 Lemmon Avenue 101, Dallas, Texas 75209, USA

Contact Details: +1 469-291-7301

Operating Hours: Tuesday – Friday: 10AM – 5PM

      Saturday: 10AM – 4PM

      Sunday – Monday: CLOSED

Google Reviews Score4.7/5 (87 reviews)
Yelp Reviews Score4.5/5 (64 reviews)
Total Reviews4.5/5 (151 reviews)
Score Consistency4.5/5
Baker’s Experience5/5
Overall Creativity4.5/5
Turnaround Time4.5/5
Customer Service4/5


  • Creative cake designs for all sorts of events
  • Huge list of unique flavors to choose from
  • Very detailed and beautiful floral cupcakes
  • Cakes are balanced in sweetness


  • May currently have decreased availability
  • Customer service is sometimes not that good
  • Occasionally doesn’t accurately follow specific requests

For Daisy Cakes, fine memories can be made at the hands of a trusty and resourceful bakery such as itself.

For years on end, it has been dedicated to the artful craft of baking custom cakes that are suited for just the right occasion. 

Creativity is, undoubtedly, a skill that should be present in all bakeries of this nature. Daisy definitely possesses this skill to a very high extent, judging by its dessert gallery and lots of happy customers.

There’s a great balance of designs that appeal to people of all ages. So whether it’s a wedding or a children’s birthday party, this is certainly a place you should consider getting a cake.

We specifically noticed that when it comes to floral themes, it does a beautiful job of sculpting them as cake decorations and cupcake toppings.

This is where you’ll see the craftsmanship that’s needed to pull off elaborate cake designs, for sure.

We’re also quite surprised about how many available cake flavors the bakery has. A lot of these flavors are ones that we’ve never even heard of before.

From the classic Cookies and Cream to fancy-sounding ones like “Kir Royale” and “Amaretto”, you’re certainly not going to run out of options with this bakery.

A common trait a lot of its cakes possess is just the right balance of sweetness, which is a great complement to the overall aesthetic that Daisy is going for.

However, some customers have experienced slight inaccuracies in the finished product, and this seems true for more complicated requests.

The shop has also lost power about a week ago, so a lot of requests have been delayed and may lead to decreased availability.

It also doesn’t really have the best customer service around sometimes, with inconsistencies and rudeness from the staff members putting off some customers.

2. Panini Bakery and Cakes

Panini Bakery and Cakes Homepage

Services and Options: 6″ Cakes, 10″ Cakes, Bride’s Cakes, Groom’s Cakes, Party Cakes, Cupcake Care Packages, Cookie Care Packages, etc.


Address: 6063 Sherry Ln, Dallas, Texas 75225, United States

Contact Details: +1 214-363-1225

Operating Hours: Tuesday – Saturday: 9AM – 4PM

      Sunday – Monday: CLOSED

Google Reviews Score4.7/5 (68 reviews)
Yelp Reviews Score4.5/5 (108 reviews)
Total Reviews4.5/5 (176 reviews)
Score Consistency4.5/5
Baker’s Experience5/5
Overall Creativity4.5/5
Turnaround Time4.5/5
Customer Service4/5


  • Highly skilled in wedding cake designs
  • Elegant and highly detailed party cakes
  • Also makes great wedding favors for guests
  • Unique and great-tasting cake fillings


  • Some cakes don’t come out that fresh
  • A bit disorganized with its operating hours

Panini Bakery and Cakes has got all you need with its custom cakes and other sweet goodies for the most special of occasions.

This is a bakery that’s rather creative with its combination of uniquely sculptured cake features and other decorations.

Whether it’s a cowboy hat made of chocolate or the entire state of Texas carved into a cake, Panini definitely has a knack for bringing the wackiest of ideas to life.

Though, we do notice that it uses a lot of props that are not exactly edible. But perhaps, it still depends on the specific requests of each customer.

If it’s something that works well with the overall theme requested, then there’s not really much issue regarding that as long as it’s executed well.

Thankfully, the bakery does execute its cakes consistently. The fillings are also one of the best that we’ve ever tasted.

It’s definitely not a place that lacks in the creativity department in any way, and its big gallery of past party cake designs surely testifies to that.

Panini also does excellent wedding cakes, unsurprisingly. The attention to detail is superb in any of its beautiful wedding creations.

To add to that, it also makes great wedding favors for guests, so definitely consider it as a caterer for your wedding.

One caveat to Panini’s services is that some cakes don’t come out that fresh, which is a bit telling of its ingredients and storage practices.

It’s also quite disorganized when it comes to its operating hours. 

It’s sometimes confusing to tell if it has a bad habit of closing at random times or is just selective of the customers that it decides to accommodate.

3. Soonja’s Bakery

Soonja’s Bakery Homepage

Services and Options: Birthday Cakes, 3D Cakes, Kids Cakes, Baby Shower Cakes, Religious Cakes, Graduation Cakes, Wedding Cakes, Cake Balls and Others, Cake Tasting, Flavors and Fillings, Delivery, etc.


Address: 5441 Alpha Rd, Dallas, Texas 75240, USA

Contact Details: +1 972-789-1700

Operating Hours: Monday – Friday: 9AM – 5PM

      Saturday: 9AM – 12NN

      Sunday: CLOSED

Google Reviews Score4.8/5 (432 reviews)
Yelp Reviews Score4/5 (108 reviews)
Total Reviews5/5 (540 reviews)
Score Consistency4/5 
Baker’s Experience4.5/5
Overall Creativity5/5
Turnaround Time4/5
Customer Service4.5/5


  • Very popular custom cake shop in the area
  • Excellent at colorful designs for birthday cakes
  • Flexible with different cake shapes and sizes
  • Also offers cake-tasting appointments


  • Sometimes difficult to contact
  • Some cakes don’t taste that good
  • Not that timely with requests on occasion

When it comes to bakeries that are no strangers to amazing cake designs, we think Soonja definitely takes the cake in a good way (no pun intended).

As one of the most popular places for custom cakes in Dallas, professionally-made creations are an everyday thing for its chefs.

Some of its designs give off a rather adorable vibe that’s quite pleasing to the eyes, and you can, quite frankly, say the same thing about its website.

We like how it doesn’t simply stick to just making cakes with a lot of different colored icing on them.

Rather, it also utilizes other forms of sweets such as donuts and cupcakes to go along with the overall theme of some cakes.

Of course, it’s all up to you if you prefer a more simplistic design. Nonetheless, it’s a creative concept that’s more than welcome on any custom cake, in our opinion.

Custom cake pops and cake balls are also nicely added options in its service, and we think these can make perfect desserts for parties and other celebrations.

Soonja’s custom cake-baking skills are just about as flexible as the ingredients that it combines and molds into all sorts of shapes.

We think you’ll be quite surprised at how excellent it can be with colorful designs, which is essential when making birthday cakes that are just so fun to look at.

The actual taste of some cakes tends to fall short, though. We think this is attributable to the bakery’s change in ownership, therefore, introducing new chefs.

It’s also pretty difficult to contact sometimes. When you do manage to get a hold of the shop and make a request, you may still experience some delays before you actually get the cake.

4. Dallas Affaires Cake Co

Dallas Affaires Cake Co Homepage

Services and Options: Wedding Cakes, Groom’s Cake, Signature Cakes, Custom Cake Orders, Cake Flavors, Cakeball Flavors, Bakery Confections.


Address: 2307 Abrams Rd, Dallas, Texas 75214, United States

Contact Details: +1 214-826-9409

Operating Hours: Tuesday – Friday: 11AM – 3PM

Saturday: 10AM – 2PM

Sunday – Monday: CLOSED

Google Reviews Score4.5/5 (92 reviews)
Yelp Reviews Score4/5 (53 reviews)
Total Reviews4.5/5 (145 reviews)
Score Consistency4.5/5
Baker’s Experience5/5
Overall Creativity4.5/5
Turnaround Time4/5
Customer Service5/5


  • Creates beautiful wedding cake designs
  • Very talented at making custom cake themes
  • Provides a lot of great signature cake templates
  • Management and staff are very friendly


  • Some cakes are inconsistent with customer’s requests
  • Cake-to-icing ratio is a bit off sometimes
  • Needs a week of preparation for custom cakes

Custom cakes made by Dallas Affaires are nothing short of elegant or amusing to look at, depending on your request.

Regardless of the type of cake you’re going for, the shop is more than capable of making creative imaginations come to life.

If we were to have a personal preference, though, we would gladly recommend having your wedding cakes at this place.

The amount of attention to detail that goes into its wedding cakes is simply something else.

If you wanted to, these cakes can definitely go on your Instagram profile for every one of your followers to behold.

But honestly, you don’t even need any fancy filters when they already look that good in person, to begin with.

Unsurprisingly, it also does a great job of making any other custom cake in so many different themes that customers come up with.

And if you happen to run out of ideas, this is where its great signature cake templates come in.

Thanks to its friendly management and staff members, cake design possibilities are endless for any customer.

Now, this doesn’t mean that all of its creations are flawless each time. Some people have also received cakes that lack specific features that they’ve mentioned.

Some of the cakes may also vary a lot in terms of the cake-to-icing ratio. We think it should chill out on the amount of icing sometimes.

Finally, you need to give the shop a call at least a week in advance for custom cakes, so that means no rush orders unless you opt for its signature cakes.

5. Sweets by Selina

Sweets by Selina Homepage

Services and Options: Corporate Event Catering, Weddings, Birthdays, Handcrafted Artisan Cakes, Custom Orders, Cupcakes, Flavors, Other Desserts, Stand Rentals, etc.


Address: 1150 Empire Central Pl suite 102, Dallas, TX 75247, USA

Contact Details: +1 972-803-8266

Operating Hours: Monday – Friday: 9AM – 5PM

Saturday: 11AM – 12NN

Sunday: CLOSED

Google Reviews Score4.6/5 (61 reviews)
Yelp Reviews Score4.5/5 (30 reviews)
Total Reviews4/5 (91 reviews)
Score Consistency5/5
Baker’s Experience5/5
Overall Creativity5/5
Turnaround Time3.5/5
Customer Service4.5/5


  • Lots of experience with cake and dessert themes
  • Artistic in all of its cake designs
  • Great at catering to all sorts of events
  • Has great-tasting cupcakes


  • Had a history of failing to deliver cakes on time
  • Custom orders require at least 7 days of notice
  • Doesn’t pick up the phone sometimes

If you fancy finding a bakery that creates custom cakes that can be all too aesthetically pleasing to bite into, then give Sweets by Selina a call.

That first sentence of ours alone can already give you a rough idea of what’s possible at the hands of Selina’s chefs.

It seems as though the limiting factor for this bakery’s creations would be the creative ideas of the customers themselves.

Judging by the solid expertise that it has, though, we think even the simplest of ideas can still yield very impressive results when turned into cake form.

After all, it’s highly artistic and resourceful when it comes to doing anything it can to satisfy the customer’s needs.

Whether the intended recipient or celebrant is a 9-year-old child or a whole corporation, it’s pretty stellar at catering to all sorts of events. 

We swear, it has created cakes that look like they defy the laws of physics, so feel free to let your imaginations run wild.

We also like to note that its cupcakes are very tasty, and we think they’re an awesome addition to your main centerpiece (the custom cake, of course).

The part where things start to fall apart for the shop is its turnaround time.

Although it doesn’t happen often enough to render it a place not even worth mentioning, it still has missed deliveries for very important events in the past.

Further adding fuel to the flame is the fact that it already has at least a 7-day notice for all custom orders.

Anyone would think that would be plenty of time to sort requests and deliveries out. But apparently, it’s not, judging by its failure to pick up the phone sometimes too.

FAQs about Custom Cakes

Related topics